Best NY-style pizza slice
in New York City

Verdict: Scarr's keeps the classic slice-shop format but uses a more careful dough program and higher-quality ingredients, making it a strong stop when you want old-school format with new-school execution. — Lower East Side

Queue: Short walk from Delancey St-Essex St.

Go: Weekday lunch or early dinner before the Friday-night Orchard Street line builds.

Price: $$

Dietary:

Verdict: L'Industrie is the modern slice benchmark for thin, crisp slices with a light base and sharp toppings; the burrata slice is the order if you want the shop's signature move. — Williamsburg

Queue: Near Marcy Ave and Bedford Ave transit corridors.

Go: Weekday afternoon; weekend lines can wrap hard around the block.

Price: $$

Dietary:

Verdict: Mama's Too! is a square-slice specialist with crisp edges, heavy cheese pull, and high-impact toppings; it is richer than a plain slice, so split a few styles if you are routing a food crawl. — Upper West Side

Queue: On Broadway near the 1 train.

Go: Late afternoon, after lunch demand and before dinner demand.

Price: $$

Dietary:

Queue: Between Broadway-Lafayette and Spring St stations.

Go: 15:00–17:00; late-night and weekend lines are the worst.

Price: $$

Dietary:

Verdict: John's is a coal-oven, whole-pie institution rather than a slice counter; it belongs here because it explains the deeper pie tradition behind the street slice. — Greenwich Village

Queue: Walkable from West 4th St and Christopher St stations.

Go: Early lunch or early dinner; whole pies only, so go with two or more people.

Price: $$

Dietary:

Verdict: Bleecker Street Pizza is useful for a classic counter slice with a stronger crust than most late-night options; the Nonna Maria slice is the house signature. — Greenwich Village

Queue: Next to the 1 train at Christopher St-Sheridan Sq.

Go: Late night after the Village bar rush starts, or mid-afternoon for no wait.

Price: $

Dietary:

Verdict: Lucia brings a Queens slice lineage into SoHo with a thin, straightforward cheese slice that works well when you need a fast stop between Chinatown and the Village. — SoHo

Queue: Near Canal St subway complex.

Go: Mid-afternoon, when Canal Street foot traffic is lower.

Price: $

Dietary:

Verdict: Patsy's is one of the city's foundational coal-oven names; use it when you want an older East Harlem pizza room rather than a slice-shop crawl. — East Harlem

Queue: East Harlem is straightforward by subway, but it is outside the Midtown tourist spine.

Go: Lunch, before the dining room fills with regulars.

Price: $$

Dietary:

Verdict: Di Fara is a pilgrimage slice for travelers who care about NYC pizza history; the value is the old-school Brooklyn craft, not convenience. — Midwood

Queue: Deep Brooklyn destination with a dedicated subway trip.

Go: Early lunch on a weekday; the trip is long enough that you should avoid peak queue windows.

Price: $$$

Dietary:

Verdict: Lucali is a whole-pie, candlelit Brooklyn classic with thin crust and minimal toppings; go when you want a destination pizza dinner, not a quick slice. — Carroll Gardens

Queue: Carroll Gardens is subway-reachable, but the waitlist system needs planning.

Go: Put your name in before opening; same-night waits are part of the process.

Price: $$$

Dietary:

Verdict: Paulie Gee's Slice Shop gives you a retro slice-counter version of a modern Brooklyn pizza brand, with both plain slices and thicker squares. — Greenpoint

Queue: The G train is useful, but Greenpoint is a deliberate detour for most visitors.

Go: Weekday lunch or early evening before Greenpoint nightlife traffic.

Price: $$

Dietary:

Verdict: Best Pizza is a reliable wood-fired slice shop with a strong white slice and simple room; it is a practical Williamsburg stop without the L'Industrie line. — Williamsburg

Queue: Short walk from Bedford Ave.

Go: Lunch or late afternoon; dinner lines rise with Williamsburg nightlife.

Price: $$

Dietary:

Verdict: F&F is the slice-counter sibling from the Frankies/Franks team, useful for clean toppings, controlled bake, and a calmer Carroll Gardens stop. — Carroll Gardens

Queue: Easy by F/G, but outside the main tourist path.

Go: Early evening before the neighborhood dinner rush.

Price: $$

Dietary:

Verdict: Louie & Ernie's is a Bronx old-school slice institution with a crisp, saucy style that rewards travelers willing to leave the usual Manhattan circuit. — Pelham Bay

Queue: Deep Bronx location with a long ride from Manhattan.

Go: Lunch if you are already in the Bronx; avoid making the trek at rush hour.

Price: $$

Dietary:

Verdict: New Park Pizza is a classic Queens slice stop known for char, speed, and neighborhood loyalty; verify transit before committing the trip. — Howard Beach

Queue: Far Queens location, easiest with a car or rideshare.

Go: Early dinner; it works best as a Queens detour, not a Manhattan snack.

Price: $$

Dietary:

Verdict: Joe & Pat's is the Staten Island thin-crust reference point, with a crackly bar-pie feel that differs sharply from a standard Manhattan slice. — Staten Island

Queue: Requires ferry plus bus/rideshare from most Manhattan itineraries.

Go: Lunch or early dinner if you are already doing Staten Island.

Price: $$

Dietary: