Monteleone Pastry Shop & Cafe
A quintessential Italian-American bakery in one of Brooklyn's most historic neighborhoods; their cheesecake is traditional, unpretentious, and priced for the local community.
Why it's in the guide
A quintessential Italian-American bakery in one of Brooklyn's most historic neighborhoods; their cheesecake is traditional, unpretentious, and priced for the local community.
The plates
2 photos · add yoursDietary
No flags filedNo dietary facts filed yet
OpenReaders who stamped here can file the first report — ask in the field notes below.
Have a dietary preference? We will surface relevant reports first.
What to order
NY cheesecake
The stamp records thisNo. 999 for NY cheesecake in New York City
How to stamp this entry
Get to the counter
Find Monteleone Pastry Shop & Cafe in Carroll Gardens (Brooklyn). Stamping unlocks when you’re within 75 m of the shop.
Order the NY cheesecake
The entry’s signature dish — the guide’s call is the NY cheesecake, and any variant counts, as long as it fits your profile.
Photograph it on site
One tap verifies time and place, then presses the stamp into your index.
In the margins
Cross-references
1 nearbyBrooklyn Bridge
Brooklyn Bridge
Pairs naturally with this food stop.
Check the route before going.
Go: after-poi
Field notes
0 filedHelp travelers behind you
Is the queue moving fast right now?
Was the price what we list?
Be the first to post a queue update or order tip in f/monteleone-pastry-shop-cafe.
0 notes from readers who went. Facts first, opinions second.
CommunityNo field notes filed yet.
Ask about the order, queue, dietary details, or stamp proof in the community.
Open community